The Indianapolis Colts have faced a tumultuous 2025 season at the quarterback position, with Anthony Richardson’s ongoing health challenges taking center stage. As a highly touted prospect selected fourth overall in the 2023 NFL Draft, Richardson has shown flashes of elite potential but has been plagued by a series of setbacks that have limited his on-field contributions. His latest injury, a fractured orbital bone sustained in a freak accident during pregame warmups, has sidelined him for much of the year, raising questions about his durability and long-term role with the team.

Richardson’s journey from a dynamic college athlete to a professional quarterback has been marked by impressive athletic feats and persistent injury concerns. Despite these hurdles, team officials and analysts remain optimistic about his abilities when healthy, citing his rare combination of size, speed, and arm strength. The Colts’ decision to bring in veteran competition and even recall a retired legend underscores the uncertainty surrounding Richardson’s immediate future.

As the regular season winds down, Richardson’s recovery progress has become a focal point for fans and experts alike. Recent developments indicate he has been cleared to return to practice, though lingering complications continue to affect his readiness. This situation has not only impacted the team’s performance but also highlighted broader discussions about player safety and quarterback development in the NFL.

Understanding Richardson’s current status requires a look back at his foundations, where his exceptional talents first emerged. Born in Miami, Florida, on May 22, 2002, Richardson grew up in an environment that fostered his athletic prowess from an early age. His early exposure to competitive sports laid the groundwork for what would become a promising but injury-riddled career.

Early Life and High School Achievements

Richardson’s formative years were spent in Gainesville, Florida, where he attended Loften High School but competed on the football team at Eastside High School. This arrangement allowed him to hone his skills against strong local competition, quickly establishing himself as a dual-threat quarterback. His high school performances were characterized by a blend of precise passing and explosive running, drawing attention from college scouts across the nation.

During his time at Eastside, Richardson amassed impressive statistics that showcased his versatility. He threw for over 4,600 yards and 37 touchdowns while adding more than 1,600 rushing yards and 41 scores on the ground. These numbers not only highlighted his physical gifts but also his ability to lead his team in high-pressure situations.

Despite facing some minor knee issues during his high school tenure, Richardson’s resilience shone through. He committed to the University of Florida, drawn by the program’s history of developing quarterbacks and its proximity to home. This decision marked the beginning of his transition to higher-level competition, where his talents would be tested against elite defenses.

High school coaches often praised Richardson’s work ethic and leadership qualities. He was known for organizing extra practice sessions and motivating teammates, traits that would carry over into his college and professional careers. These early experiences built a foundation of discipline that has helped him navigate the challenges of professional football.

College Career at Florida

Richardson’s arrival at the University of Florida in 2020 coincided with a period of transition for the Gators program. As a freshman, he saw limited action but used the time to acclimate to the speed and complexity of college football. His redshirt year provided valuable learning opportunities behind more experienced players.

2020 Season

In his debut season, Richardson appeared in just four games, preserving his eligibility through a redshirt. He completed one of two pass attempts for 27 yards, including a touchdown, but also threw an interception. This brief exposure gave him a taste of SEC competition and highlighted areas for improvement in decision-making.

Despite minimal playing time, Richardson used the season to build his physical conditioning. He focused on strength training and mobility drills, which would later become hallmarks of his playing style. Coaches noted his quick adaptation to the team’s offensive schemes during practice sessions.

2021 Season

The following year saw Richardson emerge as a backup to starter Emory Jones. He played in eight games, starting one, and demonstrated his dual-threat capabilities. Completing 38 of 64 passes for 529 yards, six touchdowns, and five interceptions, he also rushed for 401 yards and three scores.

A notable performance came against LSU, where he threw for 167 yards and three touchdowns after entering as a replacement. However, injuries began to surface, including a hamstring strain and a concussion. These setbacks limited his consistency but did not diminish his potential in the eyes of scouts.

Richardson’s rushing ability became a key weapon for the Gators’ offense. His 51 carries for over 400 yards showcased his speed and power, often turning potential losses into positive gains. This season solidified his role as a rising star in the program.

2022 Season

Taking over as the full-time starter, Richardson led the Gators to a 6-6 record in 12 games. He passed for 2,549 yards, 17 touchdowns, and nine interceptions while rushing for 654 yards and nine scores. His performance against Utah in the opener, contributing to an upset victory, was a highlight.

Against Tennessee, he recorded 453 passing yards and two touchdowns, plus 62 rushing yards and two more scores. Despite these impressive outings, accuracy issues persisted, with a 53.8% completion rate. A meniscus tear late in the season required surgery, ending his college career prematurely.

Throughout his time at Florida, Richardson’s athleticism was praised, but concerns about consistency and injury proneness emerged. He finished his college tenure with 3,105 passing yards, 24 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions, plus 1,116 rushing yards and 12 scores. These stats positioned him as a top prospect for the NFL Draft.

NFL Draft and Entry into the League

The 2023 NFL Draft saw Richardson selected fourth overall by the Indianapolis Colts, a move that excited fans with visions of a franchise quarterback. His combine performance was exceptional, including a 4.43-second 40-yard dash and a 40.5-inch vertical jump. He achieved a perfect Relative Athletic Score, joining elite company like Cam Newton.

Richardson’s physical measurements—6-foot-4, 244 pounds, with a strong arm and elite speed—made him an ideal fit for modern NFL offenses. The Colts viewed him as a high-upside player capable of transforming their attack. He signed his rookie contract and quickly integrated into the team’s system.

Pre-draft evaluations highlighted his raw talent but noted needs for refinement in footwork and reading defenses. Despite these critiques, his selection reflected the premium placed on athletic quarterbacks in today’s league. The Colts’ coaching staff expressed confidence in developing his skills.

Rookie Season in 2023

Richardson was named the starting quarterback ahead of the season opener against Jacksonville. In his debut, he threw for a touchdown, ran for another, but also had an interception in a 31-21 loss. His performance showed promise but also rookie mistakes.

In Week 2 against Houston, he scored two rushing touchdowns before exiting with a concussion, missing the following game. Returning in Week 4 against the Rams, he accounted for three touchdowns, becoming the first rookie to rush for a score in his first three starts.

Unfortunately, a grade-three AC joint sprain in Week 5 against Tennessee ended his season. He underwent shoulder surgery and was placed on injured reserve. In four games, he completed 59.5% of passes for 577 yards, three touchdowns, one interception, and added 136 rushing yards with four scores.

The injury cut short a promising rookie campaign but allowed time for rehabilitation. Team medical staff worked closely with him, focusing on strengthening the shoulder. This experience emphasized the importance of protection and decision-making to avoid hits.

2024 Season Challenges and Performances

Entering his second year, Richardson started all 11 games he played, posting a 6-5 record. He completed 47.7% of passes for 1,814 yards, eight touchdowns, and 12 interceptions, while rushing for 499 yards and six scores. An oblique injury sidelined him for two weeks.

A standout game came in Week 11 against the Jets, where he threw for a career-high 272 yards and two rushing touchdowns, including a game-winner. In Week 13 against New England, he led a 19-play drive for a go-ahead score and two-point conversion.

However, inconsistency led to a benching in Week 9 for Joe Flacco after a poor completion rate. He was reinstated after two losses. A back injury caused him to miss the final two games as the Colts missed the playoffs.

Analysts pointed to his aggressive style as both a strength and a risk factor for injuries. The season highlighted needs for improved accuracy and ball security. Despite setbacks, his dual-threat ability kept defenses on edge.

2025 Offseason and Preseason Developments

The Colts signed veteran Daniel Jones in March, setting up a competition for the starting role. Richardson participated in offseason programs but dealt with shoulder aggravation, missing minicamp. He was cleared for training camp, where the battle intensified.

QB Competition with Daniel Jones

Throughout preseason, both quarterbacks showed strengths, with Jones ultimately earning the starting nod on August 19. Richardson was named backup, with coaches citing Jones’ experience as a factor. Richardson expressed support, focusing on growth.

The competition included joint practices and scrimmages, where Richardson displayed his arm talent. However, consistency in reads remained an area for improvement. The decision reflected the team’s push for immediate stability.

Preseason Injury: Dislocated Pinky

In the preseason opener against Baltimore, Richardson suffered a dislocated pinky on his throwing hand after a sack. He was ruled day-to-day and shut down for the rest of preseason. This added to concerns about his durability in pocket situations.

Richardson completed 2-of-3 passes for 21 yards before exiting. The injury, while minor, highlighted protection issues. He returned to full practice shortly after, but it foreshadowed further health challenges.

The Orbital Fracture Incident

On October 12, during pregame warmups before a game against Arizona, Richardson fractured his orbital bone in a bizarre accident involving a resistance band. The band snapped, striking his eye area and causing immediate swelling and pain.

He was rushed to a hospital for evaluation and treatment, missing the game which the Colts won 31-27. The fracture required surgery, and he was placed on injured reserve the next day. This freak occurrence was described as highly unusual by team officials.

The incident occurred during routine band work, a common warmup exercise. Richardson later explained it as a “freaky” mishap with no major long-term eye damage beyond the bone fracture. Swelling initially impaired his vision, complicating recovery.

Recovery Process and Vision Complications

Richardson’s rehabilitation involved rest, surgery, and gradual return to physical activity. By mid-December, he was cleared medically and opened his 21-day practice window. However, persistent vision limitations in the affected eye have delayed full activation.

Head coach Shane Steichen noted that while the bone has healed, vision issues persist, affecting depth perception and clarity. Richardson has participated in limited practices, focusing on throwing and scout team reps. He acknowledged minor limitations but emphasized overall improvement.

The team has consulted specialists to monitor progress, with weekly evaluations. Richardson’s return to full contact depends on achieving 100% vision clarity. This cautious approach aims to prevent further complications in a contact-heavy sport.

Impact on the Colts’ Quarterback Room

Richardson’s absence created a ripple effect, prompting the Colts to explore veteran options. Daniel Jones started the season but faced his own challenges, leading to further adjustments. The quarterback room’s depth has been tested throughout 2025.

Philip Rivers’ Unexpected Return

In a surprising move, the Colts brought back 44-year-old Philip Rivers from retirement for the final games. Rivers, who previously played for Indianapolis in 2020, started three contests, going 0-3. He expressed no regrets, viewing it as “bonus games.”

Rivers provided stability and mentorship, completing passes in losses to Seattle, San Francisco, and Jacksonville. Teammates appreciated his willingness to help during a difficult period. His return highlighted the team’s desperation amid injuries.

Riley Leonard’s Role

Rookie Riley Leonard stepped up as backup, showing promise in limited action. He completed passes and led drives in preseason and spot duties. With Richardson sidelined and Rivers starting late, Leonard gained valuable experience.

Leonard dealt with a knee injury but remained active. His mobility and decision-making have drawn comparisons to younger quarterbacks. The Colts see him as part of their long-term plans at the position.

Career Statistics and Analysis

Richardson’s professional stats reflect his potential amid limited play. In 17 games (15 starts), he has an 8-7 record, completing 50.6% of passes for 2,400 yards, 11 touchdowns, and 13 interceptions. His rushing totals include 115 attempts for 634 yards and 10 scores.

To break down his performance further, here is a detailed list of key career highlights and areas of focus:

• Passing Efficiency: Richardson’s 67.8 career passer rating stems from a 50.6% completion percentage, which ranks low among starting quarterbacks. This has been attributed to mechanical issues and rushed decisions under pressure. Improving this metric could elevate him to elite status.
• Rushing Prowess: With 634 rushing yards and 10 touchdowns, Richardson averages 5.5 yards per carry. His speed and size make him a threat in designed runs and scrambles. This dual-threat ability has produced multiple games with over 50 rushing yards.
• Touchdown Production: He has accounted for 21 total touchdowns (11 passing, 10 rushing) in limited action. In games where he scores multiple times, the Colts’ win probability increases significantly. His red-zone efficiency stands out as a strength.
• Interception Rate: Thirteen interceptions against 11 touchdowns indicate ball security issues. Many stem from forcing throws into coverage. Coaching emphasis on check-downs has shown progress in later games.
• Injury Impact on Stats: Missing 19 games over three seasons has skewed his averages. When healthy, he averages 141 passing yards and 37 rushing yards per game. Full seasons could project him to 2,400 passing and 600 rushing yards annually.
• Preseason Performances: In 2025 preseason, he completed short passes before injuries. These outings demonstrated improved pocket presence compared to prior years. Analysts note better footwork in limited snaps.
• Comparison to Peers: Among 2023 draft class quarterbacks, Richardson’s athletic metrics surpass most, but his games played lag behind. His upside remains high if health stabilizes.
• Team Contribution: In wins, Richardson averages two total touchdowns. His mobility has extended drives, converting third downs at a 45% rate when rushing. This has been crucial in close contests.

These elements underscore Richardson’s value when available, but also the need for consistency.

Expert Opinions and Future Outlook

NFL analysts have weighed in on Richardson’s situation, with many emphasizing patience. ESPN’s analysis highlights his elite rushing as a fantasy asset, though advising caution due to injuries. NFL.com’s experts view him as a make-or-break player for 2026.

Colts GM Chris Ballard has affirmed no plans to trade Richardson, focusing on development. Coach Steichen praises his work ethic, noting gradual improvements in practice. Teammates like Nick Cross have shared positive thoughts on his leadership.

Looking ahead, Richardson’s future hinges on overcoming injury patterns. If vision issues resolve, he could reclaim the starting role. The Colts’ investment suggests long-term commitment, with potential for a breakout if durability improves.

Conclusion

Anthony Richardson’s 2025 season has been defined by setbacks, from preseason finger injuries to the orbital fracture that sidelined him for months. His career trajectory, marked by exceptional athleticism and persistent health challenges, continues to intrigue the NFL community. The Colts’ quarterback dynamics, including competitions and veteran returns, reflect the team’s efforts to stabilize the position while nurturing Richardson’s growth. As he works through vision limitations and aims for a full return, his story serves as a reminder of the fine line between potential and realization in professional football. With focused rehabilitation and strategic development, Richardson could still emerge as the franchise cornerstone envisioned in the draft.